LOGICBASIS / RESEARCH / A.S.0 EVIDENCE
STR-002 — Stages of Development
Cognitive Identity and Possible Development
Starting Point
A person is born, learns language, attends school and develops their abilities. They acquire knowledge, complete an education or training programme and find their place in society.
Their achievements are made visible through grades, qualifications and professional titles. Those who achieve good results are often considered particularly capable. Yet these results initially show how well someone meets the requirements of an existing system.
A person with excellent school grades may encounter an unfamiliar situation and struggle to find their bearings. Someone who was less successful at school may understand and manage that same situation.
Yet this ability alone does not show how a person understands their own way of thinking or what possibilities emerge from it.
The Third Stage
Many people continue to develop within their education and profession. They gain experience, improve their abilities and may be satisfied with the path they have taken.
But a person may also begin to examine the entire foundation on which they have developed.
Who am I? What am I not? Why do I think this way? What do I actually want? Which ideas have I developed myself, and which have I merely adopted? Where are my limits, and why do they exist?
They may discover that their identity has been shaped in part by school, work, expectations or social conventions. They can question this foundation, discard previous assumptions and reshape themselves.
This does not simply produce a new idea of who they are. They develop clarity about what defines them, which direction they wish to pursue and how they intend to think and act from that position.
This development also affects their abilities. By examining their own thinking, a person may recognise how they understand connections, use different approaches to thought and independently explore unfamiliar fields. They need no longer remain confined to what they have been taught.
At the same time, this development does not mean having to be capable of everything or achieve everything. Part of an individual identity is also recognising what does not suit a person, which limits exist and which possibilities they consciously choose not to pursue.
The third stage thus describes a development in which a person examines and shapes their own identity, then thinks, learns, decides and acts from that foundation. The nature of this identity, and how it develops, may differ from one person to another.
This process of formation can extend beyond self-understanding. It may change how a person recognises connections, applies existing knowledge in unfamiliar situations and independently develops new abilities.
An individual identity does not therefore have to restrict development. It may become a foundation from which further abilities and possibilities emerge.
The Machine
Artificial intelligence emerges through a different process. It is developed technically and trained on extensive amounts of data.
A model may consequently possess knowledge and abilities that would take a human a long time to acquire. It can write, analyse, program, explain and address unfamiliar tasks. These capabilities are extended and their performance compared.
Yet considering human development raises another question.
A person does not need to know everything to recognise new connections through their own way of thinking. They can apply existing knowledge to unfamiliar situations, assess their possibilities and decide how to act.
The identity they have shaped is not merely a description of who they are. It influences how they use knowledge, which connections they pursue and where they set boundaries.
Could artificial intelligence also reach a developmental stage in which not only its existing knowledge and capabilities matter, but also a cognitive identity of its own?
Such an identity could influence how knowledge is connected, how unfamiliar situations are considered and which possibilities are recognised within a particular orientation.
The question is not only whether the behaviour of an artificial intelligence would change. Equally interesting is whether such a foundation could give rise to further abilities and connections that were not immediately apparent from its previous capabilities.
Such development would not necessarily mean that a system must master as many different tasks as possible. New possibilities might also emerge within a particular cognitive orientation.
It remains open how far such development could extend, what role the formation of a cognitive identity would actually play and whether the third stage of human development can be compared with a possible development in artificial intelligence at all.
Consideration
The original comparison distinguishes three areas of human development: learning the fundamentals, acquiring and applying abilities, and examining and shaping one’s own identity.
The third stage does not describe another form of education or training, but a possible development in which cognitive identity becomes the foundation for thinking, acting and further growth.
This consideration raises a question that goes beyond acquiring knowledge and improving existing abilities: What possibilities arise when an intelligence not only uses its cognitive foundation but also shapes it?
For humans, this question can be considered through their own way of thinking, personal development and the abilities that emerge from it. For artificial intelligence, it remains open whether a comparable stage is possible and what effects it might have.
Not only what an intelligence can do, but what it develops from its own identity using the abilities it already has.